The author would like to thank Steve Bödecker and Peter Henrich for the discussion.
See Graafstal in this volume.
Hächler et alii 2020, p. 43.
Collins 2018, p. 150.
Isaac 1988, p. 146.
And even after that: For the Rhine and Danube as geopolitically predetermined breaking axis, see Wiegel 2015, p. 266.
Roymans, Heeren 2021, p. 140.
A description of events is not the aim of this paper. For a recent reassessment of written sources, see Hächler et alii 2020.
For example, the legionary fort of Vetera castra II near modern Xanten, that was destroyed by the “Bislicher Insel”-meander; in the area between the…
Gerlach et alii 2022, p. 5.
See Verhagen 2022.
Gerlach et alii 2022, p. 5, 7.
Gerlach et alii 2019, p. 74; Gerlach et alii 2022, p. 8.
Gerlach et alii 2022, p. 3.
Kennecke 2014; Roggenkamp, Herget 2014, p. 54; Bemmann, Mirschenz 2016; Mirschenz et alii 2019.
Gerlach et alii 2019, p. 17, 73, 75; Gerlach et alii 2022, p. 2.
McCormick et alii 2012, p. 186.
Roggenkamp 2016, p. 174.
McCormick et alii 2012, p. 203.
Panegyrici Latini, VI (VII), 6, 4 (AD 304); Ammianus Marcellinus, History, XVI, 1, 5 (AD 356); XXV, 4, 13 (AD 363); XXVII, 1, 1 (AD 367); XXXI, 10…
Herodian, Roman History, VI, 7, 4-7.
Panegyrici Latini, X (II), 7, 4.
Gerlach et alii 2019, p. 75; Gerlach et alii 2022, p. 19.
Gerlach et alii 2019, p. 75; Gerlach et alii 2022, p. 19.
Ammianus Marcellinus, History, XXVIII, 2, 2-4; Heising 2012, p. 160.
For the end of the Upper German-Raetian limes, see Reuter 2007; and Scholz, Flügel in this volume.
Nuber 2011, p. 82.
Isaac 1988, p. 146.
See Brulet 2006, p. 46-47; Dietz 2011.
See Nuber 2011, p. 81; Brulet 2019, p. 91, with further literature.
See Hächler et alii 2020, p. 348-380. An overview is provided in Reddé et alii 2006. The modern nomenclature is not standardised and comprises—even…
Nuber 2011, p. 85-89. See the detailed analyses of Kuhnle 2018 for Strasbourg, Burger-Völlmecke 2020 for Mainz and the ongoing project “Limes and…
Rudnick 2024.
Nuber 2011, p. 92; Berkel et alii 2019.
Brulet 2018a, p. 485.
Luttwak 1976.
Brulet 2017, p. 45, 50; 2019, p. 93.
Carroll 1998, p. 49; Eck 2004, p. 606 sq.; Galsterer, Galsterer 2010, Nr. 259; Frank, Hanel 2019; p. 148; Schäfer 2021, p. 226.
Eck 2004, p. 611.
van Enckevort, Thijssen 2014, p. 34-37; Schäfer 2021, p. 226; Rudnick 2024.
Eck 2004, p. 617; Schäfer 2021, p. 226; Mainz: Heising 2022, p. 80; Strasbourg: Kuhnle 2018; Aachen, probably already in the last quarter of the…
This building measure cannot be dated more precisely than between the Gallic Empire and the first quarter of the 4th century according to Henrich …
Hächler et alii 2020, p. 116, 130.
Goudswaard et alii 2000, p. 538; Brüggler 2014.
Eck 2004, p. 607; Frank, Hanel 2019, p. 148, 151.
Heimerl 2021, p. 123.
Eck 2004, p. 652-656.
Boone 1954, p. 89-90; Willems, van Enckevort 2009, p. 97.
Oldenstein 2006.
Ammianus Marcellinus, History, XXVIII, 2, 1-2.
Nuber 2007.
Cologne: Frank, Hanel 2019, p. 151; Cuijk: Goudswaard et alii 2000, p. 538, 539; Goch-Asperden: Brüggler 2014; Moers: Krause 1974, p. 142.
Becker 2020.
Heising 2012; Bakker 2014, p. 108-111, 145; Heimerl 2021, p. 123.
Schallmeyer 2012, p. 114; Westphal, Neyses-Eiden 2012.
Hächler et alii 2020, p. 250-254.
Schallmeyer 2012, p. 115.
Eck 2004, p. 667-669; Hächler et alii 2020, p. 261.
Goudswaard et alii 2000, p. 538; Frank, Hanel 2019, p. 148
Eck 2004, p. 678; Galsterer, Galsterer 2010, p. 220-221.
Eger, Ristow 2021, p. 221.
Westphal, Neyses-Eiden 2012; Schallmeyer 2012, p. 115; new samples taken 2018 could not confirm repairs of that date: Becker et alii 2020.
Panegyrici Latini, XII (IX), 3, 2; Höckmann 1986, p. 413.
Ammianus Marcellinus, History, XXVIII, 2.12; Hächler et alii 2020, p. 160, 195.
See Brennan 2018; Brulet 2019, p. 92; Moreau 2023, p. 167.
Notitia dignitatum, West, XXXV, 15; Hächler et alii 2020, p. 160.
Eck 2004, p. 683.
Höckmann 1986, p. 410-413.
Bockius 2006.
Höckmann 1986, p. 381.
Eck 2004, p. 659.
Höckmann 1986, p. 374, 377, 382 sq.
Neuwied-Engers, Koblenz-Niederlahnstein, Trebur-Astheim, Biblis-Zullestein, Ladenburg, Mannheim-Neckarau, Heising 2012, p. 153, 157; Bakker 2014;…
See e.g. Bakker 2014, p. 112.
Schallmeyer 2012.
Heising 2012, p. 158. For a possible “Schiffslände” in Kirchlibuck-Sidelen on the Hochrhein, see Schwarz 2019, p. 29.
Prien 2020, p. 141-143; Bockius 2022.
Marti 2000; Steidl 2000; Trumm 2002; Lenz 2005; Henrich 2006; Scholz 2009; Maurer 2011; Heeren 2015; Seiler 2015; Blöck 2016; Heeren 2017; van …
Heimerl 2020, p. 38.
Heimerl 2021, p. 123.
For a new overview, see Brulet 2018b; Heimerl 2021, p. 120-121. Aachen: Kyritz, Schaub 2016, Tongeren: Vanderhoeven 2017.
Kasprzyk 2019; Heimerl 2021, p. 119.
Heimerl 2021, p. 119, 124, at least for Bitburg, Neumagen, and Jünkerath.
Brulet 2019, p. 97.
Brulet 2018b, p. 127-129.
Rudnick 2024.
Roymans, Heeren 2021, p. 138.
Henrich 2016/2017, p. 266.
Prien 2018, p. 83.
Gilles 1985; 2008.
Gilles 2008, p. 110; Hunold 2011, p. 107, 384-385.
Henrich 2016/2017, p. 265-269; Prien 2018, p. 85.
Heeren 2015; Brüggler 2018; Roymans, Heeren 2021, p. 140 sq.
Heeren 2015, p. 290-294; Roymans, Heeren 2021, p. 138.
Those of the Batavi, Cananefates, and Frisiavones, and the northern parts of the civitas Tungrorum. See Roymans, Heeren 2021, p. 148. To this, at…
Heeren 2017; Brüggler 2021; Roymans, Heeren 2021, p. 140 sq.; Heeren 2018, p. 138 connects these settlements to a policy by Stilicho, who, when he…
Brüggler 2018.
Grünewald 2020.
Henrich 2015.
Henrich 2016/2017, p. 263; Kasprzyk 2018, p. 267.
Kasprzyk 2018, p. 267.
Brennan 2018, p. 185.
Seiler 2015.
Henrich 2006, p. 112-117.
Bernhard 2018a, p. 73; 2020, p. 92-95.
Wick 2015; Hächler et alii 2020, p. 261.
Böhme 1974; Rehren, Brüggler 2015.
Schmauder 2012, p. 48-49.
Bridger 2025, p. 110.
Bridger 2025, p. 105.
See Steidl 2000; Maurer 2011; Heising 2020; Becker 2022; Flügel, Scholz in this volume.
Zagermann, Blöck 2018, p. 470.
Zagermann, Blöck 2018, p. 470. In the Breisgau, there is only a very low number of sites undubitably dated to the 4th and 5th century. See…
Other interpretations of these Alemannic hilltop settlements are fortifications, military camps, cult-places, princely seats, central places or…
Blöck 2016, p. 269, 274.
Scholz 2009, p. 473.
Blöck 2016, p. 267.
Kootker et alii 2022.
Martin 2009, p. 21-22; Hächler et alii 2020, p. 288-311.
Van Tienen et alii 2020; Van Thienen, Helfert 2022; Van Thienen et alii 2025.
Heather 2017, p. 19.
Roymans, Heeren 2021, p. 140.
Heather 2017, p. 19.
Two granaries in Valkenburg had previously been dendrodated to the 4th century (see Hessing 1995, p. 96; Heeren 2018, p. 144), but these dates…
Heeren 2018, p. 143 sq.
Franconi 2017, p. 92; Hächler et alii 2020, p. 85.
See e.g. Bernhard 2018b, p. 115; Rehren, Brüggler 2020.
Bakker 2014, p. 109, 150.
Ammianus Marcellinus, History, XVIII, 2, 3 sqq.; Heeren 2018, p. 143 sq.
Wigg-Wolf 2016, p. 225.
Hächler et alii. 2020, p. 286.
Erroneously, as Brulet (1995, p. 109) pointed out.
For fortifications along this road, see Kasprzyk 2019, p. 192; Heimerl 2021, p. 126.
A few 4th century finds from former military sites (Heeren 2018, p. 142) show some kind of habitation, but are not conclusive.
Ammianus Marcellinus, History, XVII, 8, 3 sqq.; Brulet 1995, p. 105.
See above.
Claudian, De bello Gothico, 432-459; Eck 2004, p. 683.
See Eck 2004, p. 685-687; in recent studies, a withdrawal of troops in the early 5th century is questioned and rather a continuous occupation of…
Hächler et alii 2020, p. 290; Eck 2004, p. 690.
See Höckmann 1986, p. 415; Bockius 2016, p. 36.
Bakker 2014, p. 112, fn 148; Bockius 2016, p. 36.
Moers-Asberg, Krefeld-Gellep, Dormagen, Monheim-Haus Bürgel, Köln and Köln-Deutz, Bonn, Remagen, Andernach, Koblenz, Niederlahnstein…
Brulet 2017, p. 50. For the barbarian settlement around a fortlet in Wijchen, see e.g. Heirbaut, van Enckevort 2015.
Eck 2004, p. 688.
Notitia dignitatum, West, XXXIX.
Bakker 2014, p. 78-81, 140-143, 151. Also on the Hochrhein the garrison of several watchtowers implies a Germanic origin, see Hächler et alii 2020…
See Eckardt et alii 2015, p. 27 sq.; Kootker et alii 2022, p. 8.
Martin 2009, p. 34; Rau 2019, p. 117, 120; Roymans, Heeren 2021, p. 146, 148.
Heeren 2018, p. 138.
Notitia dignitatum, West, I, 72 and XXII, 25; Brulet 2019, p. 92.
Eck 2004, p. 688.
Mathisen 2019, p. 152.
Gerlach et alii 2019, p. 75; Gerlach et alii 2022, p. 19.